What should I order at this restaurant?

Burgers are repeatedly praised across multiple reviews for their great taste, variety, and quality. Specific mentions include the Blue Cheese Burger and the 'Burger of the day.' Guests highlight the large portions, tasty cheese, and the option for vegetarian patties, making burgers the standout dish at Gatsby.

Fries are frequently recommended as an excellent side, often noted as 'insane good' and coming in various options such as spicy fries and chili cheese fries. They complement the burgers well and are suggested for sharing.

One review specifically calls the Fish and Chips possibly the best ever had, indicating it as a highly recommended dish alongside the burgers.

Mentioned as delicious and served in generous portions, this combo is highlighted for its flavor and satisfying serving size.

This milkshake is specially noted for making a guest's day, indicating it as a delightful and memorable drink option.

Recommended as a great appetizer to share, often ordered alongside burgers and beer, making it a popular starter.

Described as delicious, the brownie is recommended as a sweet dessert option to complement the meal.