What should I order at Magnolia Bakery?

Mentioned repeatedly as the must-try and signature dessert, praised for its perfect balance of milk soak, creamy texture, and not being too sweet or heavy. Both classic and coffee variations are highly recommended, with multiple reviewers highlighting it as their favorite dessert.

Frequently cited as a best seller and a must-try item, even by those who don't typically favor banana pudding. It is described as incredible and unforgettable, often recommended as a highlight of the bakery's offerings.

Various cheesecake types like caramel pecan and mango pudding cheesecakes are noted for their deliciousness, with the vanilla cheesecake specifically called 'damn great.' Cheesecakes are appreciated for their rich flavor and quality ingredients.

Cupcakes are praised for being moist, fluffy, and flavorful with creamy frosting that is not overly sweet. They are a popular dessert choice and part of the bakery’s classic offerings.

Chocolate desserts receive positive mentions for being rich, moist, and chocolatey. The chocolate ice cream is specifically described as very yummy and highly enjoyable.