What should I order at The Old Forge Cafe?

The fish and chips are overwhelmingly praised as the best in Cornwall and possibly the best ever tasted by many reviewers. The fish portions are described as huge, cooked to perfection, and served with generous chips. The traditional preparation, including cooking chips in beef dripping, adds to their authentic and delicious appeal.

Several reviews mention mushy peas as a complementary side that is 'lush' and adds to the traditional fish and chips experience, highlighting its freshness and quality.

Some reviewers enjoyed the chips topped with cheddar, noting them as 'mint' and adding a unique twist to the classic chips, enhancing the overall meal experience.