What should I order at Mutt & Jeff's Restaurant and Bar?

The wings are highly praised for their crunchiness and flavor, with multiple reviewers noting they are the best they've ever had. Specific recommendations include the Black Garlic, FnA sauce, Hot Sofrito, and Garlic Parmesan varieties.

The mac and cheese is repeatedly described as the best ever by multiple reviewers, emphasizing its standout quality and making it a must-try dish.

The burgers are highlighted as being great and a favorite among reviewers, with specific mention of the Buckeye burger as delicious.

Recommended on Wednesdays when there's an Italian menu, the Chicken Parmesan is mentioned as a highly recommended dish, indicating its popularity during special menu days.

The steaks are noted for being surprisingly great, suggesting they can rival any steak place, making them a strong recommendation for steak lovers.

Listed among the surprisingly great dishes, the Blackened Salmon is recommended for those looking for a flavorful seafood option.

This dish is praised for being potentially the best the reviewer has ever had, with a personal touch of requesting to heat it very hot, reflecting its customizable and satisfying nature.