What should I order at Apollo Bay Bakery?

This pie is the most frequently praised dish, noted for its fresh, succulent scallops in a rich, creamy Mornay sauce with a thick, buttery, flaky crust. Reviewers highlight the perfect balance of flavors without any fishiness, describing it as a local specialty and a must-try item.

Recommended multiple times as a delicious pie option, the garlic prawns pie is loved for its chowder-like filling and generous prawn portions, offering a fresh and flavorful seafood experience similar to the scallop pie.

Mentioned positively by some reviewers for its unique flavor, described as a chowder inside a pie with generous scallop filling. However, it received mixed opinions compared to the Mornay scallop pie.

Recommended by at least one reviewer who loved the cauliflower flavor despite less broccoli content, appreciated as a tasty vegetable pie option.

Mentioned as a recommended savory pie choice alongside the scallop pie, noted for being yummy.

Liked by several reviewers, described as pretty yummy and a popular snack option.

Highly praised as the best sourdough bread on the reviewers' travels, noted for its perfect crust, great texture, and full flavor.

Recommended for its nostalgic taste similar to a McDonald's cheeseburger, adding a fun and flavorful pie option.

Mentioned as a widely enjoyed pie choice by families, appreciated for its satisfying flavor.

Recommended as a good sweet pie option complementing the savory selections.

Recommended by a reviewer who did not prefer scallops, calling it the best meat pie they’ve ever had.