What should I order at Sugar Beach Bake Shop - Kihei?

Malasadas are overwhelmingly mentioned as the must-try item, praised for being soft, warm, fluffy, and delicious with ideal sweetness. Specific flavors like ube, lilikoi, coconut, chocolate, and vanilla are highlighted repeatedly. Reviewers emphasize that the malasadas sell out quickly, indicating high demand and popularity.

The ube malasadas receive special mention as tasting heavenly and being a favorite among multiple reviewers, noted for their unique and delightful flavor.

Lilikoi (passion fruit) malasadas are frequently recommended, praised for their distinctive and delicious tropical flavor, often noted as a personal favorite.

Coconut malasadas are highlighted as a top choice for their excellent flavor, with several reviewers recommending them alongside other popular malasada varieties.

The banana bread with streusel topping is mentioned multiple times as delicious, moist, and a standout among the other pastries available.

Cookies & cream macaroons are recommended for their great taste and unique flavor, making them a favored dessert option.

Musubi, a savory Hawaiian spam sushi roll, is noted as super good and a nice savory option amidst the primarily sweet offerings.

Banana muffins are described as fluffy and fresh, a tasty breakfast choice that complements the sweeter pastries.

Scones are mentioned as delicious, fluffy, and fresh, making them a worthwhile addition to the bakery's offerings.

The coconut cake is praised for being light, not overly sweet, with a pleasant tang of pineapple in the filling, described as heavenly.

The POG tart (passion orange guava) is noted as a great pastry choice, appreciated for its tropical fruit flavors.

The ham and Swiss croissant is recommended as a savory option, appreciated for its flavor and quality.