What should I order at Over the Top Bakery Cafe?

Donuts are repeatedly praised as the best, with mentions of them being fluffy, light, delicious, and perfect for celebrations. Multiple reviewers emphasized their high quality, freshness (often warm), and excellent frosting. Varieties such as chocolate frosted Bavarian cream and pink sprinkle donuts are highlighted.

The plain cheesecake topped with strawberries is highly recommended for its light and creamy texture and generous strawberry topping. It was a favorite for a birthday celebration and stood out as a top dessert choice.

Cupcakes are noted for being moist with perfect frosting. They are a popular choice for events like weddings and showers, praised for both taste and presentation.

Apple fritters are mentioned multiple times as delicious and a must-try item, contributing to the bakery's reputation for outstanding donuts and treats.

This breakfast sandwich was described as huge and satisfying, indicating the bakery also excels in savory breakfast options.

The hummingbird cake received specific praise as the best cake ever from a wedding shower order, notable for both flavor and beautiful decoration.

Called the best ever by a reviewer, this donut variety stands out as a must-try specialty in the bakery’s donut selection.