What should I order at Thatcher McGhee's Pompton Lakes?

Mentioned multiple times as delicious and a personal favorite, even by someone who typically doesn't eat Reubens, highlighting their standout quality.

Highly praised repeatedly; one reviewer called it the best burger they've ever had in their life, indicating exceptional quality and flavor.

Frequently recommended for being awesome and outstanding, noted as a favorite appetizer among guests.

Called 'OFF THE HOOK' by a reviewer, emphasizing its freshness and exceptional taste.

Described as absolutely delicious and a satisfying meal choice by multiple guests.

Highly praised as 'to die for' by a frequent takeout customer, indicating its popularity and flavor.

Recommended specifically by a guest who praised its quality and flavor.

Part of the traditional Irish fare loved by guests, noted as delicious along with tater tots.

Mentioned positively alongside other sandwiches, indicating it as a good choice.

Reviewed as very good and recommended for those looking for a seafood option.

Described as super moist and a must-have dessert, highly recommended by customers.