What should I order at Mountain Slice Pizzeria and Creamery?

Frequently praised for its fresh house-made burrata cheese and divine hot honey topping. Multiple reviewers highlighted the burrata as a key ingredient that elevates the pizza's flavor, making it a standout choice.

Recommended as a signature slice with bacon, pepperoni, and a drizzle of honey, offering a perfect balance of tart and savory flavors. It was described as a masterpiece and a must-try by several customers.

Mentioned as a delicious specialty pizza that was loved by families and highly recommended by staff. Customers appreciated its large size and great flavor.

Noted for its smoky-sweet kick and freshly baked perfection. Reviewers found the flavor spot-on and the pizza absolutely delicious.

Highlighted for its rich, savory taste and fresh baking. Customers enjoyed the blend of cheeses and recommended it alongside other popular pizzas.

Highly recommended overall for its authentic New York style with a crispy, thin crust and high-quality ingredients. Many reviewers emphasized the authenticity and excellent flavor profile.

Recommended by staff and enjoyed by customers who tried specialty versions like the Tie Dye. It offers a distinct style and is praised for its delicious taste.

Though less frequently mentioned than pizza, the homemade ice cream from a local dairy was recommended by several reviewers, with banana chip and cookies and cream noted as popular flavors.

Suggested as a refreshing and tangy way to finish a meal, recommended by customers who tried it alongside their pizza.