What should I order at Reynolds Tavern and 1747 Pub?

The afternoon tea service is frequently praised for its outstanding quality, including fresh scones, delicate sandwiches, a wide selection of flavorful teas, and elegant presentation. Multiple reviewers noted the generous portions, excellent variety, and the overall delightful experience, making it a signature offering.

Scones are repeatedly highlighted as moist, delicious, and perfectly sweet, often mentioned as a standout item during the tea service.

Crab cakes are noted as a local favorite on the main menu, described as delicious and consistent in quality.

Pot pies are also mentioned as a local favorite, praised for their thoughtful preparation and excellent taste.

The goat cheese salad is commended for being fantastic, indicating it is a popular and well-executed dish.

Cheese curds are highlighted as fantastic, suggesting they are a highly recommended appetizer or side.

Steak frites receive positive remarks for being great, indicating strong favor among diners.

The mezze platter is described as good and is recommended as a tasty option.

Tomato soup is specifically recommended to accompany the tea service, noted for complementing the meal well.

French onion soup is also recommended alongside tea service, appreciated for its flavor and pairing.

The pub burger with fries is praised as excellent, with reviewers mentioning the impeccable service that enhances the dining experience.