What should I order at Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining?
Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining
Friday night fish fry
Multiple reviews highlight the delicious and fresh whitefish served during the Friday night fish fry, praising its quality and preparation.
Pizza
Several reviewers strongly recommend the pizza, especially noting the thin, crunchy crust and generous toppings, calling it the best pizza they've had in years.
Broasted chicken
Mentioned as excellent and well-prepared, the broasted chicken is a favorite for those who do not prefer fish.
Cherry homemade pie and other pies
The homemade cherry pie and other pies are recommended for their quality and taste, often paired with hand-dipped malts.
Cheese curds with homemade marinara
The cheese curds are noted to be delicious, especially with the homemade marinara dipping sauce.
BLT sandwich
One review mentions having the best BLT sandwich of their life, with fries that were also highly praised.
Manitou (English muffin topped with eggs, ham, and cheese)
Recommended for breakfast, the manitou is noted for its large portions and satisfying taste.
Ribs
Ribs are mentioned in multiple reviews as delicious and well-enjoyed by guests.
Meatloaf
Meatloaf is praised as a great dish with good service accompanying the meal.
About Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining
Country-chic rooms in a cozy inn offering a 1940s-themed restaurant/bar & complimentary parking.
Amenities & services
Amenities
- Free Wi-Fi
- Breakfast
- Free parking
- Air-conditioned
- Kid-friendly
- Restaurant
- Smoke-free
Frequently asked questions
What is Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining known for?
It is best known for whitefish, especially the Friday night fish fry, broiled whitefish, and whitefish livers. Reviewers call the fish fresh, well cooked, and a local delicacy, with the fish fry and livers singled out as standout Bayfield specialties.
What dishes are most recommended at Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining?
The most recommended items are the whitefish fish fry, broiled whitefish dinner, fried or pan-sautéed whitefish livers, broasted chicken, and the thin-crust pizza with lots of toppings. Reviewers also mention homemade pies, hand-dipped malts, and cheese curds with homemade marinara as memorable extras.
What is the atmosphere like at Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining?
The vibe is nostalgic and eclectic, with old records, movie-star photos, a Wurlitzer jukebox, and a space that feels like a soda fountain at the entrance and an old-school supper club farther in. It works well for families, friends, and couples who want a relaxed, history-filled meal rather than a modern, polished dining room.
Is Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining good value, and what is the price range?
The price level is not listed as high-end, and reviewers describe the food as filling, worthwhile, and worth the stop, especially for the whitefish dinners and pizza. The combination of hearty portions, quick service, and a downtown Bayfield location makes it feel like solid value for a casual meal.
How long is the wait at Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining?
Wait time is a recurring theme in reviews, but guests often say the service stays quick even on busy Saturday nights. Several reviewers mention that food arrived promptly and the experience was still smooth, especially when dining on the patio or stopping in for pizza or a fish dinner.
Why use AI food recommendations?
Skip the Menu
No need to trust waiters or get overwhelmed by the menu
Explained Choices
Provides context and explanations for why each dish is recommended
Find things to do & top restaurants in any city