What should I order at New Sarum Diner?

Highly praised for being cooked and flavored to perfection with standout white meat, stuffing, and gravy. The all-you-can-eat sides and the traditional style of the meal exceed expectations, making it a must-try.

Recommended multiple times for its excellent preparation, especially the haddock used instead of the usual cod. Described as amazing and delicious, a favorite among visitors including those from out of town.

Noted for excellent seasoning, crispy texture, and served with applesauce on the side. Frequently mentioned as very good and a standout dish.

Mentioned several times and appreciated for being cooked perfectly with mashed potatoes and gravy, though opinions vary slightly among reviewers.

Recommended for its great taste and paired well with some of the best fries mentioned by reviewers.

Both desserts are repeatedly highlighted as the best, with apple crisp and other desserts like Mexican deep fried cheesecake making the A list for sweetness lovers.

Mentioned as a delightful nostalgic treat, especially the chocolate milkshake, complementing the retro diner experience.