What should I order at this restaurant?

Pizza is overwhelmingly praised across multiple reviews for its fantastic flavor, quality toppings, and hot, flavorful crust. Specific types like the Pagliai Special, meat extravaganza thin crust, all meat pizza with wood-fired flavor, everything pizza (often customized with banana peppers), broccoli pizza with wheat crust, and vegetable deluxe on wheat crust were mentioned positively. The pizza is considered the best in town by several reviewers.

Recommended especially for vegans due to accommodating dietary needs with vegan cheese. Described as incredibly delectable and a pleasant surprise for vegan diners.

Mentioned as a favorite alongside pizza, noted for being wonderful and delicious.

Mentioned once positively as a good appetizer complementing the pizza.

Frequently commended for being fresh, clean, and having good options including vegan-friendly choices. It is highlighted as a perfect and affordable accompaniment to meals.