What should I order at The Old Mill?

Recommended multiple times for being perfectly cooked, tender, and flavorful. Reviewers noted it was done right to their medium rare preference and very impressive.

Praised for being juicy, full of flavor, and the best burger in the area according to a reviewer. Multiple mentions highlight its deliciousness.

Highly recommended for being fried perfectly with just the right amount of seasoning. Several reviewers enjoyed the crab claw dishes, calling the portions generous and the flavor excellent.

Noted for being oven seared to perfection and cooked properly to requested doneness, making it stand out in the reviews.

Mentioned as very flavorful and cooked perfectly, with multiple reviewers recommending it as a great seafood option.

Recommended by a picky eater who loved it and finished their plate clean. It was also described as a delicious dinner choice.

Long-time favorite for some reviewers and noted as very good, despite portion size changes.