What should I order at Jimmy's Grotto Inc?

Ponza Rotta is the most frequently praised dish, described as huge, delicious, and fresh. Many reviews highlight its quality, size, and authentic taste, with some recommending ordering ahead due to wait times. The Ponza Rotta is noted as a must-try and a nostalgic favorite across generations.

The Deluxe Ponza Rotta is specifically mentioned several times as having great size, taste, and value for price. It is highlighted as 'stupid cheap' and delicious, recommended especially for those wanting a more loaded version of the classic Ponza Rotta.

The Chicken Bacon Calzone is recommended as a delicious and filling meal. It is praised for its quality and flavor, standing out as a favorite calzone option alongside the Ponza Rotta.

The Italian Sausage Sandwich is recommended by a long-time visitor as consistently worth buying. It complements the Ponza Rotta as one of the notable savory offerings at Jimmy's Grotto.

Fried Ponza Rottas are recommended for their taste and texture, with some reviewers specifically calling them delicious and suggesting to try the fried version of the calzone.

Although less frequently mentioned, the burger is praised as the best burger one reviewer has ever had, noted for being very well made and a worthwhile departure from their usual Ponza Rotta order.

Fried Raviolis are highlighted by a reviewer as 'dangerously delicious,' suggesting they are a tasty appetizer or side worth trying.