What should I order at Old Florida Fish House?

Repeatedly praised as the best key lime pie by multiple reviewers, noted for its deep dish style, homemade whipped cream, and perfect graham cracker crust, making it a must-try dessert.

Called the best lobster wontons ever by more than one reviewer, described as absolutely a must-try with excellent flavor, highlighting it as a standout appetizer.

Highly recommended by multiple guests for being fresh, perfectly cooked, and satisfying. Variations include House Grouper and crab-encrusted grouper with mashed potatoes, indicating it is a popular main dish.

Mentioned several times as grilled to perfection, tender and flaky, with one reviewer calling it perfect, making it a favored seafood choice.

Frequently highlighted for freshness and creativity, with sushi described as some of the best in town and sashimi especially praised, indicating the restaurant's strong sushi offerings.

Noted as good and delicious by several reviewers, sometimes paired with mashed potatoes and shrimp, marking it as a well-liked seafood entree.

Mentioned for being plump and bursting with ocean-fresh flavor, enjoyed as both a starter and main dish option.

Described as delicious by a reviewer, indicating it is a recommended non-fish entree with flavorful appeal.