What should I order at Tony's Crab Shack?

The crab sandwich is mentioned repeatedly across reviews as a must-try item. It is praised for being loaded with fresh, generous portions of crab meat, often described as tender and delicious. Many reviewers highlight the quality of the bread (garlic toast, grilled sourdough) and the overall freshness, making it a standout item. It's frequently called the 'famous' or 'original' crab sandwich and is highly recommended by many customers.

Clam chowder is another frequently recommended dish, noted for its creamy and flavorful taste. While one reviewer mentioned it was a bit thin, most found it outstanding and a perfect complement to the crab sandwich. It’s often paired with sandwiches and highlighted as a great addition to the meal.

The seasonal smoked salmon sandwich with cranberry sauce is well-liked and recommended by multiple reviewers. It is described as fantastic, with generous portions of fish and a unique flavor combination that stands out.

Crab cakes receive high praise in several reviews, with one reviewer calling them the best they've had in the United States. They are noted for being amazing and flavorful, making them a highly recommended choice for seafood lovers.

Fish tacos are mentioned a few times as tasty and enjoyable. They are recommended as a good alternative or additional seafood option alongside the crab sandwich and other dishes.

Lobster roll is noted by some customers as a delicious option, with mentions of it being the finest in town. Although not as frequently mentioned as the crab sandwich, it is still recommended by several reviewers.

Oysters, both raw and broiled, are highly praised for their freshness, size, and flavor. They are described as some of the best oysters customers have had in a long time and are recommended for seafood enthusiasts.

The tuna melt is mentioned positively in at least one review as being simply delicious and highly recommended, adding variety to the seafood offerings.