What should I order at Sam's Restaurant?

Pizza is repeatedly praised as the best in East Hampton, with mentions of great thin crust, large portions, and delicious toppings like shrimp, crab meat, pesto, and gorgonzola. Many reviewers highlight it as a favorite for families and locals, and the Mediterranean pizza is specifically noted for its hypnotizing aroma and solid taste.

The Chicken Milanese is highly recommended for being really good, juicy, perfectly seasoned, and a treat that many enjoy. It is mentioned multiple times as a standout dish that people return for.

The Rigatoni Vodka is described as the best ever had by a reviewer, praised for its rich flavor and loved by the whole family. It is noted as a must-try pasta dish.

The roasted chicken is highlighted for being absolutely delicious, juicy, perfectly seasoned, and cooked to perfection with full flavor in every bite.

Garlic bread is mentioned as perfect and a great accompaniment to the meal, indicating consistent quality and satisfaction.

Spaghetti Bolognese is recommended as a classic Italian dish that is irresistible and well-prepared, contributing to the overall excellent Italian comfort food experience.

Baked Ziti Bolognese is noted as another favorite dish that complements the traditional Italian menu and satisfies longtime diners.

Chicken Parm is praised for being fantastic with big portions, lots of sauce, and not dry, making it a reliable choice for diners.

Mussels are mentioned as a delicious appetizer served in large portions, adding variety beyond pizza and pasta.