What should I order at Brewster's New Buffalo?
Brewster's New Buffalo
Betty White pizza
Mentioned multiple times as having an excellent sourdough crust that is light and airy, with ricotta, roasted garlic cloves, and hot honey making it stand out. It is considered one of the best pizzas and highly recommended by several reviewers.
Bruschetta
Frequently recommended as a must-have appetizer that is shareable and delicious. Several reviews praise its flavor and consistency, making it one of the top starter choices at the restaurant.
Cacio e Pepe
Highly recommended pasta dish praised for its amazing flavor and quality. It was mentioned as a standout dish after the restaurant's remodel and is suggested by multiple reviewers.
Detroit Style Pizza (Triple Crown Detroit Style deep dish)
Recommended as a must-try pizza option with hot honey, noted for its delicious taste and shareable size. It is highlighted as a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Desserts (Brownie Caramel Tiramisu, Sticky Toffee Pudding, Tiramisu, Carrot Cake, Cookies)
Desserts receive high praise for being outstanding and memorable. Several specific desserts like the brownie caramel tiramisu and sticky toffee pudding are called '10/10' and 'so good,' with cookies also noted as spectacular.
Olives and Whipped Feta Dip
Mentioned as a flavorful and dreamy appetizer, this dip is well-liked and recommended as a great starter to share.
Shrimp Alfredo
Highlighted as a delicious main entrée option, praised for its flavor by reviewers who enjoyed it as part of their meal.
Lemon Basil Chicken
Recommended by a reviewer who called it incredible, suggesting it as a flavorful main course choice.
Berry Pancakes with Berry Sauce
Mentioned as a standout breakfast item with fresh flavors, recommended for brunch visitors.
Hours
| Monday | 9 AM to 10 PM |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 9 AM to 10 PM |
| Wednesday | 9 AM to 10 PM |
| Thursday | 9 AM to 10 PM |
| Friday | 9 AM to 10 PM |
| Saturday | 9 AM to 10 PM |
| Sunday | 9 AM to 10 PM |
About Brewster's New Buffalo
Handcrafted regional Italian food in cafe environs with homey decor & a windowed atrium bar.
Amenities & services
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Delivery
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Fast service
- Fireplace
- Great beer selection
- Great cocktails
- Great coffee
- Great dessert
- Great wine list
- Serves local specialty
Popular for
- Breakfast
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Hard liquor
- Private dining room
- Small plates
- Vegan options
- Vegetarian options
- Wine
Dining options
- Breakfast
- Brunch
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Counter service
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Bar onsite
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Quiet
- Romantic
- Trendy
- Upscale
Crowd
- Family-friendly
- Groups
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Tourists
- Transgender safespace
Planning
- Dinner reservations recommended
- Accepts reservations
- Usually a wait
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
- Usually somewhat difficult to find a space
Frequently asked questions
What is Brewster's New Buffalo known for?
It is especially known for the Betty White pizza, which reviewers describe as having a light sourdough crust, ricotta, roasted garlic, and hot honey. People also praise the house-made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and the fast, friendly service that makes busy nights still feel worth the wait.
What dishes are most recommended at Brewster's New Buffalo?
Reviewers repeatedly recommend the Betty White pizza, meatballs, bruschetta, chicken tortellini soup, biscuits and gravy, and the Dinner for Two. Breakfast fans also call out berry pancakes with berry sauce, scrambled eggs a la carte, and the Mary’s Mess breakfast plate.
Is Brewster's New Buffalo good value, and what is the price range?
The price range is $10 to $50, and reviewers specifically say the prices are right for breakfast and that the Dinner for Two is an incredible value. Portions are described as generous, and even lunch plates and shared meals are said to feel worth the cost.
When is the best time to visit Brewster's New Buffalo?
Dinner reservations are recommended because the restaurant is often busy and usually has a wait, especially on peak nights. Reviewers say the food is worth waiting for, and downtown New Buffalo gives people a place to walk around while they wait.
Is parking available at Brewster's New Buffalo?
Yes. Free parking lot, Free street parking, Usually somewhat difficult to find a space is available.
Does Brewster's New Buffalo have vegetarian options?
Yes, Brewster's New Buffalo offers vegan options.
Is Brewster's New Buffalo kid-friendly?
Yes, Brewster's New Buffalo is good for kids.
Restaurants like Brewster's New Buffalo in New Buffalo
Why use AI food recommendations?
Skip the Menu
No need to trust waiters or get overwhelmed by the menu
Explained Choices
Provides context and explanations for why each dish is recommended
Find things to do & top restaurants in any city