What should I order at The CODfather, Proper Fish ?

This dish is overwhelmingly praised across multiple reviews for having perfectly crispy, light, and non-greasy batter with fresh, flaky cod. The portions are described as huge and satisfying, with hand-cut fries that complement the fish well. Many reviewers call it the best fish and chips they have had, some even comparing it favorably to UK standards. The classic wrapping and tartar sauce also add to the authentic and enjoyable experience.

Mentioned positively as a delicious alternative to fish and chips, the seafood pie received high marks for taste, with at least one reviewer calling it 'Chef’s kiss' and expressing a desire to return for more.

Though less frequently mentioned, the curry pie was noted for being surprisingly tasty and a good substitute when the meat pie was unavailable.

The butty, consisting of a whole fish filet on a bun, was recommended for its wonderful taste and the addition of very good homemade tartar sauce.

Often paired with the fish and chips, the mushy peas were appreciated for their clean flavor and traditional style without added sugar, contributing to the classic British meal experience.