What should I order at Pequod's Pizza?

The deep dish pizza is the most frequently praised dish, with many reviewers highlighting its hearty size, perfectly caramelized and crispy cheese crust, rich and flavorful sauce, and generous toppings like sausage, pepperoni, and Canadian bacon. The crust is described as unique, more like bread, and the caramelized edges are a standout feature. Reviewers consistently mention being very full after just a slice or two, emphasizing its satisfying nature.

Among the toppings on the deep dish pizza, pepperoni and sausage are repeatedly mentioned as favorites. The sausage is noted for being extra seasoned and fragrant, while the pepperoni provides a crispy texture and flavorful bite. These toppings are often recommended together and praised for complementing the sauce and crust well.

The house salad is positively noted in multiple reviews, especially when paired with the garlic dressing. It is described as tasty and a good complement to the pizza, providing a lighter option to balance the richness of the deep dish.

Some reviewers enjoyed the jalapeño poppers as a starter, highlighting the cream cheese filling as superior to the typical artificial cheese found elsewhere. Though not everyone was impressed, the jalapeño poppers are recommended by certain guests for their quality and flavor.

Mentioned as a good side dish, the cheesy garlic bread is recommended alongside the pizza. It is noted for being tasty and enhancing the overall meal experience.

As a dessert option, the Bananas Foster Cheesecake receives positive remarks for its taste, rounding out the dining experience with a sweet finish.