What should I order at this restaurant?

Helped 0 people skip menu & eat good food.

May Kelly's Cottage

4.7 (1644 reviews)
4 people skipped menu from this restaurant
#1

Shepherd's Pie

Frequently praised for its flavor and included in the popular pie trio sampler; highlighted as a flavorful and standout dish among traditional Irish fare.

#2

Beef Stew

Mentioned multiple times as part of the pie trio and praised for its great flavor, contributing to the authentic Irish dining experience.

#3

Chicken Pot Pie

Often part of the trio sampler and noted for its delicious crust and overall taste, with several reviewers enjoying it especially.

#4

Corned Beef and Cabbage

Highlighted as a comforting and well-prepared traditional Irish dish, described as 'out of this world' and 'so good'.

#5

Irish Coffee

Highly recommended drink noted for its quality and authenticity, with several mentions calling it a 'must have' alongside meals.

#6

Blueberry Bread Pudding

Recommended dessert that impressed diners with its delicious taste and uniqueness as an Irish bread pudding.

#7

Irish Sampler

A popular choice allowing guests to try several traditional dishes; frequently noted as delicious and a great way to experience the menu.

#8

Roast Turkey Dinner

Mentioned as excellent and a hearty option, with one reviewer highlighting it as a reason to visit again, especially around Thanksgiving.

#9

Irish Nachos

A favored appetizer unique for using potatoes instead of tortilla chips, enjoyed by multiple guests.

#10

Reuben Sandwich

Called a highlight by guests, noted for its quality and flavor as part of the sandwich offerings.

Why use AI food recommendations?

Skip the Menu

No need to trust waiters or get overwhelmed by the menu

Explained Choices

Provides context and explanations for why each dish is recommended