What should I order at Delmar Pizzeria?

Frequently praised for its unmatched and unparalleled taste and quality. The unique dough makes the crust light and crispy, and it stands out as a favorite among many reviewers.

Highly recommended for its creamy and smooth sauce with a good amount of bacon. Considered by some as the best Alfredo slice they've had anywhere and a consistent favorite for years.

Noted for its perfect crust and freshness, making it a popular choice. Reviewers appreciated the fresh pan-made slices and the perfect texture of the crust.

Mentioned as a favorite for its fresh ingredients and delicious flavor, highlighting the quality and taste of the pizza.

Recommended for being made with very high-quality ingredients and considered the best pizzeria option in the Sheepshead Bay area.

A longtime favorite due to its tight, non-sloppy filling with a thin layer of dough, making it a standout item beyond just pizza.

Praised as a classic item that only a few pizzerias still make well, favored by regular customers for its quality.

Mentioned as an excellent dish, showing that the restaurant's quality extends beyond pizza.

Highly praised, with one reviewer noting it changed their mind about New York pizza, signifying its exceptional quality.