What should I order at The Mill Supper Club?
The Mill Supper Club
Prime Rib
Frequently praised for its flavor, tenderness, and perfect cooking, often accompanied by creamy horseradish and au jus. Multiple reviewers highlighted the king cut prime rib as a highlight of their meal.
Pan Fried Perch
Highly recommended for its fresh taste, perfect cooking with a crispy outside and tender inside, served with traditional sides like potato and coleslaw. Many guests specifically chose the perch for Friday fish dinners.
Cajun Shrimp Pasta / Cajun Shrimp Alfredo
Mentioned multiple times as delicious and generously portioned, this dish combines flavorful Cajun seasoning with shrimp and pasta, earning high praise from several reviewers.
Broasted Chicken
Recommended as a Sunday night special and praised for its quality and value. Served family style with traditional sides, it is noted as a comforting and satisfying classic supper club dish.
Walleye Dinner
Noted for its excellent preparation similar to the perch, with perfect spicing and crispiness, making it a favorite among fish dishes at the restaurant.
Salad Bar
Consistently mentioned as fresh, well-stocked, and a highlight of the meal experience. Reviewers appreciate the quality and selection of greens and toppings.
Poutine (Curry Poutine)
Surprisingly praised by a reviewer who was initially not a fan of poutine but found the curry poutine to be exceptional and a standout dish.
Spätzle
Mentioned as part of the German dishes that are well-loved, noted for its authenticity and excellent taste.
Schnitzel
Described as excellent and flavorful, often paired with spaetzle, this dish is a popular choice for those enjoying traditional German fare.
Whitefish Chowder
Recommended for being rich, creamy, and full of ingredients like whitefish, potato chunks, and herbs, making it a comforting starter.
Old Fashioned (cocktail)
The bar’s Old Fashioned cocktail is frequently praised for being perfectly made and a great way to start the meal.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4 to 8 PM |
| Friday | 4 to 9 PM |
| Saturday | 4 to 9 PM |
| Sunday | 4 to 8 PM |
About The Mill Supper Club
The Mill Supper Club is an American, fine dining, and German restaurant in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin. Reviewers consistently praise the prime rib, fish fry, broasted chicken, spaetzle, and the salad bar, along with fast service and well-made drinks. The atmosphere is described as casual, cozy, and historic, with a bar area that feels nostalgic and a dining room that is clean and spacious. It is popular for dinner and solo dining, and the price range is listed at $20 to $30.
Amenities & services
Service options
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great beer selection
- Great cocktails
- Great dessert
- Great wine list
- Serves local specialty
Popular for
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Alcohol
- All you can eat
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Happy hour drinks
- Happy hour food
- Hard liquor
- Salad bar
- Wine
Dining options
- Dinner
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Bar onsite
- Restroom
- Wi-Fi
- Free Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Historic
Crowd
- Family-friendly
- Groups
- Tourists
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- Has changing table(s)
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
- Usually plenty of parking
Frequently asked questions
What is The Mill Supper Club known for?
It is especially known for prime rib, including king cut prime rib with au jus and creamy horseradish, plus Friday fish fry plates like pan fried perch and walleye. Reviewers also call out the salad bar, broasted chicken, and German dishes such as spaetzle and curry poutine.
What dishes are most recommended at The Mill Supper Club?
Reviewers most often recommend the prime rib, pan fried perch, walleye, broasted chicken, and spaetzle. Other specific favorites include the whitefish chowder, curry poutine, and the salad bar, which is repeatedly described as fresh and well stocked.
What is the atmosphere like at The Mill Supper Club?
The restaurant has a casual, cozy, historic supper club feel, with a nostalgic bar and a larger dining room that feels clean and roomy. It suits couples, groups, and solo diners, and reviewers mention that the pace and service make it comfortable for a relaxed dinner.
Is The Mill Supper Club a good value, and what is the price range?
The listed price range is $20 to $30, and reviewers often say the portions and quality make it worth the cost, especially for prime rib, fish dinners, and the Sunday broasted chicken special. A few guests note that a night out can feel steep, but many still describe it as a special-occasion meal that leaves them full.
What should I know about drinks and service at The Mill Supper Club?
The bar is a highlight, with reviewers praising old fashioneds, cocktails, beer, and a strong wine list, and several mention the drinks as a reason to come early before dinner. Service is repeatedly described as fast, friendly, and well paced, with hosts and servers making recommendations and keeping dinner moving smoothly.
Is parking available at The Mill Supper Club?
Yes. Free parking lot, Free street parking, Usually plenty of parking is available.
Is The Mill Supper Club kid-friendly?
Yes, The Mill Supper Club is good for kids.
Restaurants like The Mill Supper Club in Sturgeon Bay
Why use AI food recommendations?
Skip the Menu
No need to trust waiters or get overwhelmed by the menu
Explained Choices
Provides context and explanations for why each dish is recommended
Find things to do & top restaurants in any city