What should I order at Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant?
Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant
Deep dish pizza
By far the most frequently praised item in the reviews. It’s repeatedly described as delicious, cheesy, flavorful, filling, and the closest thing to real Chicago-style pizza outside Chicago.
Garlic pesto bread
Mentioned as especially standout and even 'to die for,' with one reviewer saying they would return just for this item alone.
Cheesecake
Specifically called out as a dessert option, with both the strawberry and original cheesecake mentioned in a positive context as something the reviewers tried and enjoyed.
Cookies
Recommended as very good, with reviewers noting they are served warm with whipped cream, making them a memorable dessert choice.
Caesar salad
Mentioned as part of a highly enjoyed meal and specifically praised alongside the deep-dish pizza as a dish worth ordering.
House salad
Described as good and fresh, with one review also highlighting the ranch dressing as excellent.
Hours
| Monday | 11:30 AM to 9 PM |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM to 9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM to 9 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM to 9 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM to 9 PM |
About Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant
This long-running pizzeria in a historic building specializes in Chicago-style deep-dish pies.
Amenities & services
Service options
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Great beer selection
- Great wine list
- Serves local specialty
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Happy hour drinks
- Happy hour food
- Late-night food
- Wine
Dining options
- Brunch
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Counter service
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Bar onsite
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Historic
- Trendy
Crowd
- College students
- Family-friendly
- Groups
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Tourists
- Transgender safespace
Planning
- Dinner reservations recommended
- Accepts reservations
- Usually a wait
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
- Usually somewhat difficult to find a space
Frequently asked questions
What is Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant known for?
It is best known for Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, with reviewers repeatedly calling it the closest thing to real Chicago pizza in the North Bay. People also mention that even a small pie is very filling, so the deep dish stands out for both flavor and portion size.
What dishes are most recommended at Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant?
The most recommended items are the deep-dish pizza, especially versions with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, and fresh tomatoes, plus the garlic pesto bread. Reviewers also mention the Caesar salad, thin crust pizza, warm cookies with whipped cream, and cheesecake, but the deep dish and pesto bread are the most consistently praised.
What is the atmosphere like at Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant?
The vibe is casual, cozy, and historic, with reviewers describing the downtown Petaluma building as having old-time charm, brick walls, chandeliers, and a maze-like layout. It works well for groups and families, and several reviews note that the space can be noisy and open enough that kids do not feel out of place.
Is Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant good value, and what is the price range?
The price range is $10 to $20, and reviewers often say the pizza is pricey but worth it because a small deep-dish pie can feed two people or leave leftovers. One review noted about $27 total for two people before tip, which lines up with the filling portions and makes it feel like solid value for deep dish.
When is the best time to visit Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant?
Go early in the evening if you want to avoid a wait, because reviews and the restaurant data both say dinner can be busy and reservations are recommended. Several diners also mention that the pizza takes a while to arrive, so it is a better choice when you are not in a rush.
Is parking available at Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant?
Yes. Free parking lot, Free street parking, Usually somewhat difficult to find a space is available.
Is Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant kid-friendly?
Yes, Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant is good for kids.
Restaurants like Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant in Petaluma
Why use AI food recommendations?
Skip the Menu
No need to trust waiters or get overwhelmed by the menu
Explained Choices
Provides context and explanations for why each dish is recommended
Find things to do & top restaurants in any city