What should I order at Rosie’s Amagansett?

Recommended multiple times for being especially well-prepared: one review called it the best in the Hamptons, and another said it was delicious with a flavorful pesto sauce alongside it.

Frequently praised as a standout item, with reviewers saying they came back specifically for them and describing them as phenomenal, delicious, and not dry.

Strongly recommended for its rich, indulgent texture and flavor, with reviewers highlighting the sizzling cast-iron presentation, bronzed top, and molten, cheesy center.

Mentioned as a favorite brunch item and even described as arguably the best this side of California, showing it as a standout breakfast choice.

Praised as a generous, rich special loaded with tender lobster and served hot, making it a memorable comfort dish.

Recommended because one reviewer said they were the best their daughter had ever had, which makes them a notable brunch favorite.

Called the best the reviewer had in a very long time and praised for being made with extra care and love.