What should I order at Nicky's on the Bay?
Nicky's on the Bay
Crab Cakes
Recommended multiple times for being fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked; several reviews called them amazing or excellent.
Lobster Bisque
Praised as rich and flavorful, with a generous amount of lobster, and described as amazing in one review.
Braised Short Ribs
Mentioned more than once and consistently praised for being delicious and very tender, with one review saying they were 'like butter' and another calling them melt-in-your-mouth.
Shrimp Cocktail
Noted as fresh and excellent, and highlighted as a strong appetizer choice in multiple positive reviews.
Lobster Roll
Called fresh and flavorful, and singled out as one of the standout dishes in a positive review.
Halibut
Recommended for being spot on and well prepared, with one review specifically praising the Parmesan Halibut.
Thai Chili Calamari
Recommended as a fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked starter that made a strong impression.
Chicken Milanese
Mentioned as part of a set of dishes that were all described as delicious.
Shrimp Scampi
Included among the dishes that reviewers said were delicious and worth trying.
Everything-Crusted Tuna
Praised for being fresh and well-seasoned, making it a standout entrée.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM to 10 PM |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 11 AM to 10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM to 10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM to 10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM to 10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM to 10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM to 9 PM |
About Nicky's on the Bay
Casual eatery on a pier where a fish-centric menu pairs with bar specials, live music & bay views.
Amenities & services
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Onsite services
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Coffee
- Happy hour drinks
- Happy hour food
- Hard liquor
- Wine
Dining options
- Brunch
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Seating
Amenities
- Bar onsite
- Restroom
Crowd
- Family-friendly
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Has changing table(s)
Parking
- On-site parking
- Paid parking lot
- Paid street parking
- Usually plenty of parking
Frequently asked questions
What is Nicky's on the Bay known for?
Nicky's on the Bay is known for fresh seafood served with water views, especially dishes like hot lobster rolls, lobster bisque, shrimp scampi, crab cakes, and Parmesan halibut. Reviewers also consistently mention the attentive service and the setting on the bay with views of ferries, boats, and sunsets.
What dishes are most recommended at Nicky's on the Bay?
Frequently recommended items include the hot lobster rolls, lobster bisque, shrimp cocktail, crab cakes, everything-crusted tuna, and Parmesan halibut. Reviewers also praised the braised short ribs, chicken Milanese, mussels, clams, street corn, and monkey bread a la mode for being fresh or well-prepared.
What is the atmosphere like at Nicky's on the Bay?
The atmosphere is described as welcoming, polished, and scenic, with indoor seating, outdoor seating, and a rooftop area overlooking the water. It seems to suit couples, groups of friends, and families, especially people who want a relaxed meal with live music, drinks, and sunset views.
Is Nicky's on the Bay good value, and what is the price range?
Nicky's on the Bay is listed at $$, and reviewers describe the prices as reasonable for some meals but also note that the bill can add up, especially with drinks and premium items like the New York strip. The value is often tied to the freshness of the seafood, strong cocktails, and the waterfront experience.
Do you need a reservation or is there a best time to visit Nicky's on the Bay?
Reservations are accepted, and one reviewer mentioned making a same-day reservation after starting at the bar. The best time to go seems to be around sunset or on a summer afternoon, when the water views, boats, and ferry traffic are part of the experience.
Is parking available at Nicky's on the Bay?
Yes. On-site parking, Paid parking lot, Paid street parking, Usually plenty of parking is available.
Restaurants like Nicky's on the Bay in Bay Shore
Why use AI food recommendations?
Skip the Menu
No need to trust waiters or get overwhelmed by the menu
Explained Choices
Provides context and explanations for why each dish is recommended
Find things to do & top restaurants in any city