What should I order at Hat Creek Burger Company?

Most reviewers praised the burgers overall for being juicy, flavorful, fresh, and among the best they’ve had. Specific burgers like the Pretzel Jack, Bacon Royale, Little Hat Burger, Pizza Burger, and Truff Burger were all highlighted positively, showing the restaurant’s burgers are the main draw.

Fries were mentioned multiple times as a strong side item, with reviews calling them crispy, fluffy, well-seasoned, and a good complement to the burgers. Loaded fries were also specifically called out as amazing.

The tots were recommended as worth the upcharge and especially good when paired with the restaurant’s Hat Sauce. Reviewers liked them enough to order extra sauce for them.

The Hat Sauce was singled out as the best sauce by one reviewer and praised as something worth getting extra of, especially for dipping burgers and tots.

Milkshakes were described as divine and the best the reviewers had had, making them one of the standout menu items beyond the burgers.