What should I order at Il Pirata Mellieha Bay?

Pizza is mentioned numerous times as a highlight, praised for its authentic Neapolitan style, well-hydrated dough, fresh and proper ingredients like spicy ventricina salami, and unique slow fermentation process. Specific pizzas like Boscaiola, Spianata, and Calzone Napolitano are also recommended for their rich, light, and delicious qualities.

Calamari fritti is repeatedly noted as fresh and insanely good, with positive remarks from families including kids, highlighting it as a great seafood choice.

Seafood pasta is mentioned as a perfect dish enjoyed by guests, indicating high quality and freshness.

Oysters are highlighted as amazing and fresh, recommended by reviewers who appreciated the seafood options.

The octopus meal receives specific praise, contributing to the restaurant's reputation for excellent seafood.

This dish is noted for its delicious Mexican cheese and overall great taste, offering a well-liked non-pizza option.

Mussels are mentioned positively alongside pizza, suggesting they are a good seafood choice at the restaurant.