For better restaurant suggestions, allow location access to see nearby places first.
Seafood restaurant in Bainbridge Island, Washington
What should I order at Proper Fish?
What to order
-
🥇
Fish And Chips
Most frequently praised dish in the reviews, repeatedly called the best, freshest, crispiest, and most flavorful item on the menu. Reviewers also loved the huge portions, light batter, tender fish, and that it was cooked fresh to order.
-
🥈
Chowder
Mentioned multiple times as excellent or delicious, with reviewers specifically praising it alongside the fish and chips as a strong menu item worth trying.
-
🥉
Onion Rings
Described as massive, crispy, and delicious, with one reviewer saying they were big enough to be a meal on their own.
-
4
Mushy Peas
Recommended as a good side that paired well with the meal; reviews highlighted the pea and mint version as excellent and noted it balanced the fish and chips nicely.
-
5
Tartar Sauce
Praised for being unique, nicely flavored, and delicious, with several reviewers mentioning it as a standout accompaniment to the fish.
-
6
Lobster Roll
Mentioned positively by some reviewers as part of an enjoyable meal, though it was less consistently praised than the fish and chips.
-
7
Fish Tacos
One reviewer said they would get them again, noting that the flavor was awesome and the fish was not greasy.
-
8
Fish Sandwich
Also recommended by a reviewer who said they would order it again, praising its flavor and saying it looked and tasted much better than expected.
Details
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM to 8 PM |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 11 AM to 8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM to 8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM to 8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM to 9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM to 9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM to 8 PM |
About Proper Fish
Chill joint specializing in British-style fish ‘n chips & standard seafood fare with beer/wine.
Amenities
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Frequently asked
What is Proper Fish known for?
Proper Fish is best known for its British-style fish and chips, especially the fresh fish, crispy batter, and hot fries that reviewers say arrive quickly and taste made to order. The tartar sauce also gets repeated praise for being unique and delicious.
What dishes are most recommended at Proper Fish?
The most recommended items are the fish and chips, chowder, lobster roll, fish tacos, and fish sandwich. Reviewers also call out the onion rings when available, plus the fries with vinegar and the pea and mint mush as standout sides.
What is the atmosphere like at Proper Fish?
The atmosphere is casual, modest, and relaxed, with counter service, self-seating, and both indoor and outdoor seating. It seems to suit groups and casual lunch stops well, since reviewers mention sharing large portions and sitting down quickly even when the place is busy.
Is Proper Fish good value, and what is the price range?
Yes, many reviewers describe it as reasonably priced, and one review specifically notes fish and chips at $22. The portions are often described as huge or shareable, so the value is helped by how much food you get for the price.
How long is the wait at Proper Fish during busy times?
Wait times can vary, but several reviewers say the line gets long quickly, especially around lunch and on tourist-heavy days on Bainbridge Island. Even so, food often comes out in about 5 to 20 minutes after ordering, though one busy visit took about 50 minutes.
