For better restaurant suggestions, allow location access to see nearby places first.
What to order
-
🥇
Mango Crab Cakes
Mentioned multiple times as divine, tender, and cooked to perfection, making it one of the most consistently praised appetizers.
-
🥈
Fried Key Lime Pie
Called out by several reviewers as a standout dessert and something you should not leave without trying.
-
🥉
Conch Fritters
Repeatedly described as tasty, delicious, and not heavy with filler, making them a popular appetizer choice.
-
4
Shrimp Po Boy
Praised as delicious, with one reviewer also complimenting the coleslaw that came with it.
-
5
Lobster Roll
Recommended for its fresh, generous lobster meat and buttery toast; one reviewer said it was the best item they had.
-
6
Hogfish
Reviewers raved about the catch of the day prepared stuffed and francaise, calling it the best fish they had ever had.
-
7
Key West Shrimp Pasta
Described as the perfect shrimp pasta and also praised as excellent in a sunset dinner review.
-
8
Lobster Shrimp Egg Rolls
Specifically recommended as a must-try item, with reviewers highlighting the generous filling and great flavor.
-
9
Mahi Mahi
Mentioned in several positive reviews in different preparations, with comments that it was well-seasoned, cooked perfectly, and spot on.
Details
Hours
| Monday | 8 AM to 10 PM |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 8 AM to 10 PM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM to 10 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM to 10 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM to 10 PM |
| Saturday | 8 AM to 10 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM to 10 PM |
About Island Fish Company
Waterside tiki bar/eatery pairing seafood classics such as coconut shrimp with frozen drinks.
Amenities
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Frequently asked
What is Island Fish Company known for?
It is especially known for grouper, conch fritters, lobster roll, and sunset views over the water in Marathon. Reviewers repeatedly call out fresh, well-seasoned fish, seafood plates, and the waterside setting as the main reasons people go.
What dishes are most recommended at Island Fish Company?
The most recommended items include the grouper, conch fritters, lobster roll, mango crab cakes, shrimp po boy, and deep fried key lime pie. Reviewers also mention the blackened mahi, shrimp and lobster egg rolls, coconut shrimp, and crab dip as standouts.
What is the atmosphere like at Island Fish Company?
The vibe is a casual waterside tiki bar with outdoor seating, dock views, and sunset watching, plus indoor seating that reviewers describe as cozy and not overly loud. It works well for couples, groups, and families, since people mention anniversary dinners, date nights, and tables with plenty of room.
Is Island Fish Company good value, and what is the price range?
Reviewers describe it as wallet friendly and well worth the cost, especially for the amount of food, drinks, and water views you get. The menu is in the restaurant category rather than a fine-dining setting, and guests often say portions are generous, such as the giant burger and plates that leave you full.
When is the best time to visit Island Fish Company?
An early dinner around 4:30 can mean easier parking and seating, while Friday nights and off-season weekends can still be busy but often have shorter waits than expected. Several reviewers note that the wait is worth it, and some spend the time taking photos by the water or on the little pier.
