What should I order at Mill Creek Gardens?

Most reviews highlight the wide variety of Kawartha Dairy ice cream flavors available, with over 50 flavors offered. Customers appreciate the excellent taste, reliable quality, large portions, and options including vegan, gluten free, and dairy free. It is repeatedly praised as the best ice cream in town and a must-try.

Specifically mentioned as a flavor tried and enjoyed by a returning customer, indicating it is a popular and tasty choice among the many flavors available.

Also mentioned alongside Pralines and Cream by a repeat visitor, suggesting it is another well-liked flavor option at the shop.

Mentioned as a very yummy item ordered from the menu, showing that in addition to scoops, their milkshakes are also recommended by customers.