What should I order at The Bayfield Inn?

It is best known for its lakefront and harbor views, especially from the rooftop restaurant and dining room. Reviewers repeatedly mention watching the lake, pier, and sunsets while eating or having drinks, which is a big part of the experience in Bayfield.

Reviewers specifically highlight the blackened whitefish with mixed vegetables and garlic potatoes, stuffed French toast, and the breakfast menu’s mix of classic and unique options. The side salad with cranberries and nuts and the hot roll also get called out as especially good.

The vibe is described as chic, cozy, and laid-back, with big windows and open seating that keep the focus on the water views. It seems to work well for couples, solo diners, and groups who want a scenic meal or evening drinks on the rooftop or inside dining room.

The price range is not listed in the data, but reviewers suggest good value because the food is described as fresh, homemade from scratch, and served in a prime waterfront location. Several guests say the meals arrive quickly and the experience is worth returning for, especially for breakfast and dinner with a view.

Breakfast is a strong choice if you want lake and pier views through the dining room windows, while early dinner and evening drinks are popular for harbor and sunset views. Reviewers also note that getting a table early was easy, and the rooftop patio is especially appealing when it is open.