What should I order at Halldórskaffi?

Mentioned repeatedly as excellent, perfectly cooked, fresh, and tasty. Many reviewers highlight it as a standout dish, often paired with salads or potatoes, and recommend it highly.

Frequently praised for its delicious, well-toasted bread and flavorful meat. Reviewers often enjoyed it alongside lamb soup or on its own, calling it fantastic and highly recommended.

Described as exceptional with perfectly airy and crisp dough, fresh ingredients, and harmonious flavors. Some reviewers compared it favorably to authentic Italian pizza and found it delicious.

Highly recommended by multiple reviewers who noted fantastic cakes and pies, incredible desserts, and positive surprise from dessert tarts. Often mentioned as a must-try to finish the meal.

Described as fresh, homemade, hot, and fantastic tasting. Recommended by those who tried it alongside the lamb sandwich.