Link copied to clipboard

What should I order at Cotton Exchange?

Helped 0 people eat good food

Cotton Exchange

4.4 (971 reviews)
You are 1 of 32 skippers at this restaurant
🥇

Steak (including Ribeye)

Mentioned multiple times as tender, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The ribeye and prime rib were specifically praised for their excellent preparation and taste.

🥈

Prime Rib Sunday Brunch

Highly recommended for its value and quality, with an all-you-can-eat offering including prime rib. Customers noted it as a reason to visit and praised the variety and taste.

🥉

Fried Fish (Cod)

Described as a generous and satisfying portion with sides like potato pancakes, coleslaw, and tartar sauce. Several reviewers enjoyed this dish and found it filling and delicious.

4

Chili Salmon

Recommended for its fresh ingredients and flavorful oriental vegetables, standing out compared to other restaurants that use frozen vegetables.

5

Omelet with everything

One reviewer called it the best omelet they’ve ever had, highlighting the freshness and taste at the Sunday brunch.

6

Specialty Drinks (e.g. Pineapple Upside-Down Martini)

Drinks were frequently praised for their taste and reasonable pricing, with the pineapple upside-down martini specifically mentioned as amazing.

Location details

345 Hickory Hollow Rd, Waterford, Wisconsin, 53185, US

Open in Google Maps

Hours

Monday 4 to 8 PM
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 4 to 8 PM
Thursday 4 to 8 PM
Friday 4 to 9 PM
Saturday 4 to 9 PM
Sunday 10 AM to 7 PM

About Cotton Exchange

Classic American fare, including a Sunday prime-rib brunch, in a restored barn & banquet hall.

Amenities & services

Service options

  • Delivery
  • Onsite services
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Highlights

  • Fast service
  • Fireplace
  • Great beer selection
  • Great cocktails
  • Great coffee
  • Great dessert
  • Great wine list
  • Serves local specialty

Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings

  • Alcohol
  • Beer
  • Cocktails
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
  • Happy hour drinks
  • Happy hour food
  • Hard liquor
  • Healthy options
  • Private dining room
  • Wine

Dining options

  • Breakfast
  • Brunch
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Catering
  • Dessert
  • Seating
  • Table service

Amenities

  • Bar onsite
  • Restroom
  • Wi-Fi
  • Free Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Cozy
  • Historic
  • Trendy

Crowd

  • Family-friendly
  • Groups
  • Tourists

Planning

  • Brunch reservations recommended
  • Dinner reservations recommended
  • Accepts reservations

Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards

Children

  • Good for kids
  • High chairs
  • Kids' menu

Parking

  • Free parking lot
  • Free street parking
  • Usually plenty of parking

Frequently asked questions

What is Cotton Exchange known for?

Cotton Exchange is best known for its fish fry and prime rib, including a Sunday brunch that features sliced prime rib with breakfast sides. Reviewers also frequently mention ribs and steaks, especially for their tenderness and solid value compared with nearby steakhouses.

What dishes are most recommended at Cotton Exchange?

Reviewers repeatedly recommend the fried fish or fish fry with cod and potato pancakes, the prime rib, and steaks like Steak Oscar and the 10 oz filet. The Sunday brunch omelet also gets strong praise, with guests calling it one of the best they have had.

What is the atmosphere like at Cotton Exchange?

The atmosphere is described as casual, cozy, historic, and a little trendy, with exposed wood, a fireplace, and a country feel. It suits groups, families, and solo diners, and it is also used for weddings and bridal showers because of the banquet-style setting and attentive service.

Is Cotton Exchange good value, and what is the price range?

Cotton Exchange is in the $20 to $30 range, and reviewers say it is very reasonable for the portion sizes and quality. One Sunday brunch was described as all you can eat for $23 with prime rib, and steaks were noted as being under $40 while still coming with salad or soup, vegetables, rolls, and baked potatoes.

Do you need reservations for brunch or dinner at Cotton Exchange?

Reservations are accepted, and reviewers specifically say Sunday brunch reservations are a must. That makes sense for the popular prime rib brunch and fish fry service, especially on busier days when people recommend picking your time carefully.

Is parking available at Cotton Exchange?

Yes. Free parking lot, Free street parking, Usually plenty of parking is available.

Is Cotton Exchange kid-friendly?

Yes, Cotton Exchange is good for kids.

Restaurants like Cotton Exchange in Waterford

Why use AI food recommendations?

Skip the Menu

No need to trust waiters or get overwhelmed by the menu

Explained Choices

Provides context and explanations for why each dish is recommended

Skip Menu
Skip Menu
The easiest way to find what to eat, wherever you are.
Download the App