What should I order at Tony's Seafood Restaurant?

Oysters are the standout item mentioned repeatedly across many reviews, praised for their freshness, variety of preparations, and exceptional taste. They are often described as the best, with some reviewers overcoming their previous bias against oysters. The Hog Island oysters are especially highlighted.

The clam chowder is frequently recommended and described as unique, silky smooth, full of fresh clams in the shell, and one of the best clam chowders people have ever had. It is noted for being flavorful and a must-try dish.

The seafood stew is mentioned multiple times as a popular, excellent dish with a great mix of seafood. Although one review noted the broth could use more seasoning, overall it is highly recommended and enjoyed by many.

Specifically highlighted for their delicious flavor, grilled oysters with garlic butter are a favorite among guests and frequently recommended as a must-order item.

Steamed mussels are praised as excellent and a standout shellfish option loved by diners.