What should I order at The Walrus and the Carpenter?

Oysters are overwhelmingly praised across multiple reviews for their freshness, perfect shucking, and variety. They are highlighted as the standout item with customers appreciating the daily handpicked selection and knowledgeable staff guidance.

Clams are noted in a couple of reviews as being particularly delicious and well-prepared, often mentioned alongside the oysters as a must-try shellfish option.

Deviled eggs receive positive mentions for their taste and quality, being singled out as an excellent dish along with oysters and other seafood.

The bread served with a large rock salt butter is specifically recommended for its deliciousness and as a favorite item enhancing the overall dining experience.

The albacore crudo is praised for its fresh and balanced flavors, recommended as a favorite dish complementing the seafood offerings.

Grilled sardines are highlighted as amazing and exquisite, with some reviewers considering them a top dish alongside the oysters.

The tartare is appreciated for its great texture and flavor, though some found it a bit salty, it is generally recommended as a worthwhile dish.

The panna cotta dessert is described as super creamy and delicious, providing a satisfying way to finish the meal.