What should I order at The Pickled Herring?
The Pickled Herring
Whitefish (including whitefish tacos, sandwich, blackened whitefish, and whitefish po'boy)
Mentioned multiple times as delicious, flaky, tender, and juicy. Customers consistently praised various preparations of whitefish, highlighting it as a standout dish.
Chili
Repeatedly recommended and described as outstanding and delicious, making it a popular choice among diners.
Fish Fry
Called incredible and a must-stop for fish fry enthusiasts, indicating it is a highly recommended and well-executed dish.
Cheese Curds
Noted as very good and enjoyable even by those who are not typically fans of fried cheese, highlighting their appeal.
Sweet Potato Fries/Wedges
Frequently mentioned as delicious and generous in portion size, often paired with fish dishes.
Steak Naan
Praised as so delicious it could be an entree on its own, indicating strong flavor and quality.
Fish Livers
Recommended for adventurous diners and described as tasty when sautéed with onions and peppers.
Split Pea and Ham Soup
Specifically highlighted as worth the trip, indicating it is a flavorful and memorable menu item.
Chicken Alfredo
Mentioned as really loved by a diner, showing it is a well-prepared and popular dish.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
|---|---|
| Tuesday | 11 AM to 8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM to 8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM to 8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM to 9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM to 9 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM to 4:30 PM |
About The Pickled Herring
The Pickled Herring is a bar and grill in Bayfield, Wisconsin, known for Lake Superior whitefish, fish fry, and other comfort food served with lake views. Reviewers consistently praise the whitefish, fish sandwich, fish fry, and sides like sweet potato wedges, chips with horseradish sauce, and coleslaw. The restaurant also gets strong marks for friendly service, fast service, and outdoor seating overlooking the water. It is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining, and the price range is listed as $20 to 30.
Amenities & services
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great beer selection
- Great cocktails
- Serves local specialty
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Food
- Food at bar
- Hard liquor
- Quick bite
- Small plates
- Wine
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Bar onsite
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Trendy
Crowd
- Groups
- Tourists
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
- Usually plenty of parking
Pets
- Dogs allowed outside
Frequently asked questions
What is The Pickled Herring known for?
It is best known for Lake Superior whitefish, especially the blackened whitefish, whitefish and fries, and fish sandwich. Reviewers repeatedly call the fish flaky, tender, and juicy, and many also mention the fish fry as a standout.
What dishes are most recommended at The Pickled Herring?
The most recommended items include the blackened whitefish, whitefish and fries, fish sandwich, fish fry, and poutine, plus sides like sweet potato wedges and homemade chips with horseradish sauce. Reviewers also singled out the cheese curds, steak naan, surf and turf, and soups like wild rice soup and split pea and ham soup.
What is the atmosphere like at The Pickled Herring?
The vibe is casual, cozy, and a little trendy, with outdoor seating that overlooks Lake Superior and a bar area that reviewers describe as fun and welcoming. It seems to work well for groups and couples, and the dining room is quiet enough for conversation.
Is The Pickled Herring good value, and what is the price range?
The listed price range is $20 to 30, and reviewers often say portions are large enough to share or leave you very full. People also note that the quality of the whitefish, cocktails, and sides makes the meal feel worth the cost.
When is the best time to visit The Pickled Herring?
Many reviewers mention stopping in before or after an Apostle Islands cruise, since the restaurant is right across from the docks. Outdoor dinner seating with a lake view is a recurring highlight, and the place is also praised for fast service if you are on a schedule.
Is parking available at The Pickled Herring?
Yes. Free parking lot, Free street parking, Usually plenty of parking is available.
Is The Pickled Herring kid-friendly?
Yes, The Pickled Herring is good for kids.
Restaurants like The Pickled Herring in Bayfield
Why use AI food recommendations?
Skip the Menu
No need to trust waiters or get overwhelmed by the menu
Explained Choices
Provides context and explanations for why each dish is recommended
Find things to do & top restaurants in any city